Mitchell's Steakhouse - Downtown

Mitchell's Steakhouse - Downtown
Restaurant Cuisine: Seafood, Steakhouse
45 N 3rd St
Columbus, OH 43215-3509
#3
of 1040 restaurants in Columbus
TripZen Score
8.5 / 10 Overall
197% Recommend
8.5Overall8.5Food
8.5Food
Activities: Health club, Hot tub, Pool (outdoors)
Check-in / Check-out time: 11am / 3pm
Description:Experience The Modern American Steakhouse. Mitchell’s Steakhouse, raises the bar again, offering the best steak, seafood and wine in Columbus, Ohio. Our hand selected prime steaks are aged to perfection. Or choose your favorite cut from our selection of true Japanese Kobe beef. Our house made side dishes don’t just ...Read more
A breakfast nook.
Mitchell's Steakhouse - Downtown Map

Traveler Reviews

TripZen Score
8.5 / 10 Overall
197% Recommend
8.5Overall8.5Food
8.5Food
Overall
  • We had a wonderful experience and the food was fabulous
  • Mitchell's steak house was one of the great steak places in columbus.
  • every thing was great, and had a great at the restaurant
  • A beautiful restaurant with a great atmosphere.
  • We had a wonderful experience.
  • It is a wonderful group spot for special occasions and large parties as well as a romantic night out.
  • Restaurant was great as usual.
  • Everything was great.
  • The dining experience is exceptional.
  • Our second experience at Mitchell's Downtown was just as wonderful as the first.
  • I loved this place!
  • What a great experience.
  • Everything was excellent.
  • I know it will produce a wonderful experience for them and myself.
  • Everything was perfect!
  • I have to say, this place is positively stunning.
  • We were in a great spot, right along third street.
  • was looking for a great steakhouse.
  • We were celebrating our 3 year anniversary and everything was perfect.
  • But all in all, it was a nice experience and I would return.
  • Everything was still fantastic!
  • One of the best Cameron Mitchell restaurants in Columbus.
  • Mitchels is one of the best places in Columbus to visit on special occasions!
Food
  • We had a wonderful experience and the food was fabulous
  • Mitchell's steak house was one of the great steak places in columbus.
  • The food was fabulous and the service was top notch.
  • Outstanding service and attentiveness plus superb food
  • The bar area is nice for a glass of wine as well.
  • The steak was great, but salad and dessert were very disappointing....Nevertheless, except for the steak, the food quality was sub-par.
  • Food was great, service was outstanding -
  • The bar makes very good drinks
  • Food was very good and very expensive.
  • The dining experience is exceptional.
  • To start, they both had the lobster bisque and loved it...The sides of broccoli, corn and baked potato were all prepared to perfection.
  • Great Steak.
  • The meal at Mitchell's Steakhouse in downtown Columbus last Friday was remarkable!...The 4 oz filet mignon, which was cooked to perfection at medium rare, was possibly the best steak I have ever had in my entire life....The lobster maccaroni and cheese (lobster mac) was an excellent side dish, and well worth the extra money....The mashed potatoes and fresh-baked bread and butter were also excellent.
  • Oysters Rockefeller was best I've ever had;...lobster bisque was excellent;...dessert of carrot cake was average.
  • The food was superb.
  • Very enjoyable,good,friendly service,excellent food,and hope to be back soon.
  • One of my top dining experienced overall in a long time.
  • The food at Mitchell's was excellent, as usual.
  • The service and the food at this Mitchell's, now closed, was impeccable
  • Large portions with great preparation.
  • This was by far, one of the best "Prime" steaks in Central Ohio!
  • The food was good but not exactly as great as we expected.
  • The food was very, very good.
  • Great steak, cordial and efficient staff, beautiful room.
  • The staff gave us special attention and the delivery timing of the food was perfect.
  • Salad had three really small pieces of beef(good quality, I'll admit) and the most drab ceasar salad.
  • The food was great.
  • True upper-crust dining.
  • the entrees we had were some of the best ever!
  • The food was delicious and the service was great.
  • The food was delicious
  • Our dinner was delicious, the service was outstanding...we were treated to a complimentary dessert.
  • Excellent steak....Great wine list.
  • Salad, soup, bread, and wine leading up to the main course were all excellent....Our server could have been around to check in a little more, but other than that, what a wonderful meal!...It was a nice finish to a wonderful meal.
  • Nice service, good food at a very reasonable price ....Lamb chops were tasty, chopped salad was great, and appetizers were solid.
  • Filet Mignon was perfectly prepared and tasted great.
  • The food is always cooked to perfection, exactly the way we like it.
Service
  • Service was dis-interested, which could be good for business discussions.
  • The food was fabulous and the service was top notch.
  • Outstanding service and attentiveness plus superb food
  • table service was good.
  • The service was good, but not a outstanding as I expected.
  • Food was great, service was outstanding -
  • The wait staff is very courteous, not pushy about food drinks or anything else
  • that was really dissapointing as we have had wonderful service by waitresses before who took their time at the table and checked back frequently....We would definately be sure to request a "seasoned" server next time to ensure the wait staff doesn't spoil an otherwise wonderful experience.
  • John, our waiter, was wonderful.
  • The atmosphere was romantic and the service was excellent.
  • The service was excellent.
  • Very enjoyable,good,friendly service,excellent food,and hope to be back soon.
  • The waitress was very nice and very responsive.
  • The service I felt was a little slow at times, but better than having them breathe down your neck the whole time.
  • The server was prompt, knowledgable and accommodating.
  • Great steak, cordial and efficient staff, beautiful room.
  • Excellent Service.
  • The service was great.
  • The service was impeccable and the atmosphere was great.
  • The food was delicious and the service was great.
  • the service was very attentive to our needs and wants.
  • Our dinner was delicious, the service was outstanding
  • Great service, white-cloth napkin is always classy.
  • Always great service and food.
  • Nice service, good food at a very reasonable price .
  • Service was attentive and polite.
  • Excellent service, friendly and very attentive!
Ambience
  • Great atmosphere for business lunches and delicious food.
  • The reception desk gals were warm and friendly...table service was good.
  • A beautiful restaurant with a great atmosphere.
  • the ambiance was wonderful.
  • Great steak, cordial and efficient staff, beautiful room.
  • I asked for a quiet table when I made my reservation
  • The service was impeccable and the atmosphere was great.
  • The ambiance is wonderful.
  • I enjoy the ambiance of the downtown Mitchell's.
  • First of all, I just love the decor.
Value
  • Food was very good and very expensive.
  • It is a place we will return to but only for special occassions because of the price.
  • Nice service, good food at a very reasonable price .

Top Rated Restaurants in Columbus

See all restaurants
The Refectory Restaurant and Bistro The Refectory Restaurant and Bistro Columbus, OH 43220
9 Overall
Yanni's Greek Restaurant Yanni's Greek Restaurant Columbus, OH 43231-1614
8.5 Overall
Eddie Merlot's - Columbus Eddie Merlot's - Columbus Columbus, OH 43240
8.5 Overall

Top Rated Hotels in Columbus

See all hotels
Cambria Suites Cambria Suites Columbus, OH 43240
9 Overall
Hilton Columbus/Polaris Hilton Columbus/Polaris Columbus, OH 43240
9 Overall
Hampton Inn & Suites Columbus Polaris Hampton Inn & Suites Columbus Polaris Columbus, OH 43240
9 Overall