Mama's Fish House

Mama's Fish House
Restaurant Cuisine: Seafood, Hawaiian
799 Poho place
Paia, Maui, HI
#1
of 25 restaurants in Paia
TripZen Score
8.5 / 10 Overall
294% Recommend
8.5Overall8.5Food
9Food
Activities: Health club, Hot tub, Pool (outdoors)
Check-in / Check-out time: 11am / 3pm
Description:Mama's Fish House is actually a converted beach house in a coconut grove on a secluded white sand beach. Inside, hinged windows open to let in the trade winds and Polynesian artifacts and original oil paintings decorate tropical hardwood walls. The rooms are filled with spectacular flower arrangements and tapa ...Read more
A breakfast nook.
Mama's Fish House Map

Traveler Reviews

TripZen Score
8.5 / 10 Overall
294% Recommend
8.5Overall8.5Food
9Food
Overall
  • Great atmosphere, terrific food, and a great place!
  • Best restaurant experience on Maui -...Everything else was fabulous.
  • This was our second time to Mama's Fish House and it was an outstanding experience.
  • Overall experience was spectacular.
  • It was an amazing restaurant.
  • Truly a wonderful experience.
  • The ambience, food, service, and everything were exceptional!
  • Everything was excellent.
  • This restaurant is worth the accolades that it has earned.
  • as good as any top end restaurant in Los Angeles or better.
  • A great restaurant with an amazing location.
  • You couldn't ask for a better place to have a lovely dinner.
  • A very unique experience dinner that surpassed all expectations.
  • This is the best restaurant experience I've EVER had...Mama's featured impeccable service, a sublime food experience...nearly made me weep with joy to the stuffed macadamia-encrusted mahi mahi to the "black pearl" dessert, everything was absolutely flawless!
  • They have a perfect spot on the beach -...It is a large restaurant, very touristy spot --
  • My 4th visit and it's just as fantastic as my first....The view, well, there's no restaraunt that can compare!
Food
  • Shrimp appetizer was outstanding.
  • The baked Mahi Mahi was terrific....Great atmosphere, terrific food, and a great place!
  • It was the best meal we had on Maui.
  • I will appreciated the wine list value for the wine we ordered with our meal as well.
  • Meal was best we ever had
  • In all cases the food and the service have been superb.
  • The food was just OK
  • Its a little pricey and they have mostly authentic food, which is excellent quality
  • My wife and I loved the food and the atmosphere.
  • The menu is simple and not overwhelming.
  • Our meal was unique and creative
  • The ambience, food, service, and everything were exceptional!
  • The setting is spectacular and the food fantastic!
  • This was a special dinner for our son and soon to be daughter-in-law who were married the next day....We knew it would be great from cocktail to dessert that is why we selected it.
  • The Lobster and the stuffed Mahi Mahi are so good it is difficult to describe to others....NEVER had a bad meal or a reason to complain.
  • The food and the service was outstanding.
  • Thoroughly enjoyed the food.
  • Food on the adult menu was good, but small portions....Kids said their food was the worst they'd had on Maui.
  • We felt a bit rushed during the dinner-but it was some of the best food we have ever had.
  • Our dinner at Mama's was the culinary highlight of our week in Maui.
  • The food was wonderful.
  • Stunning grounds and gorgeous vistas greet you for a delicious and romantic dinner.
  • great seafood....unique blend of asian and pacific flavors.
  • You couldn't ask for a better place to have a lovely dinner.
  • The service was fantastic, the food was delicious
  • Lunch was expensive (27- 48 dollars an entree), but absolutely exceptional....It was an expensive entree, but he absolutely loved it.
  • Special macadamia nut crusted stuffed fish was excellent;
  • Food,setting, service and overall ambiance were lovely.
  • A memorable meal with our teenage children....Outstanding food, service and views!
  • Dinner was excellent, food and ingredients were fresh, fragrant and local.
  • beautiful setting and good food.
  • Fish prepared so well I will never want to eat fish anywhere else!
  • nearly made me weep with joy to the stuffed macadamia-encrusted mahi mahi to the "black pearl" dessert, everything was absolutely flawless!
  • The menu items are a pricey
  • Our kids were treated like princesses by the staff, the food was fresh and well-prepared
  • Kitchen was a bit slow on Monday after Easter.
  • The food was excellent
  • The food was incredible.
  • Great dinner!
  • The food is fabulous though very expensive.
  • The menu was really nice with almost all locally caught fish on the evening menu (with the fishermans name next to it).
Service
  • The service was impecable, the atmosphere was delightful and breathtaking...my server she was a very knowledgeable, pleasant, and attentive to our every needs.
  • On this occasion, Danny's service was excellent.
  • The staff are very friendly and accomodating.
  • The ambience, food, service, and everything were exceptional!
  • Your staff is very polite and professional.
  • The food and the service was outstanding.
  • The servers were very helpful by answering our questions about the menu items.
  • Our waitress was very nice and very friendly, I am sorry I can't remember her name
  • Their food is always excellent, service is top notch
  • Outstanding food, service and views!
  • The service was fantastic, the food was delicious
  • Service was attentive but not overwhelming or over-friendly.
  • the view, setting, service, and food is spectacular.
  • Mama's featured impeccable service, a sublime food experience
  • Excellent service.
  • The service was excellent!
  • The staff couldn't have been more friendly, and gave excellent food .
  • The service was exceptional.
Ambience
  • Great atmosphere, terrific food, and a great place!
  • We sat at a table by the window that had wonderful views of the ocean.
  • The service was impecable, the atmosphere was delightful and breathtaking
  • The Restaurant is in a beautiful setting.
  • My wife and I loved the food and the atmosphere.
  • if you like that style.
  • The ambience, food, service, and everything were exceptional!
  • A great restaurant with an amazing location.
  • you get all this with a great view.
  • Outstanding food, service and views!
  • The location and ambiance of this restaurant is incredible, worth the drive, stay and explore the surroundings.
  • the view was incredible!
  • the view, setting, service, and food is spectacular.
  • beautiful setting and good food.
  • it will look SPECTACULAR if you get the right table.
  • The view, well, there's no restaraunt that can compare!
  • The view was magnificent.
  • the presentation of every dish beautifully done.
  • The view is incredible and a perfect opportunity for taking pictures.
Value
  • I will appreciated the wine list value for the wine we ordered with our meal as well.
  • we understand why the prices are so high
  • Lunch was expensive (27- 48 dollars an entree), but absolutely exceptional.
  • There is far better value to be found in Maui.
  • The menu items are a pricey
  • The food is fabulous though very expensive.

Top Rated Restaurants in Paia

See all restaurants
Mama's Fish House Mama's Fish House Paia, Maui, HI
8.5 Overall
Paia Fish Market Paia Fish Market Paia, Maui, HI 96779
8.5 Overall
Flatbread Company Flatbread Company Paia, Maui, HI 96779
8 Overall

Top Rated Hotels in Paia

See all hotels
Paia Inn Hotel Paia Inn Hotel Paia, Maui, HI 96779
9 Overall
The Inn at Mama's Fish House The Inn at Mama's Fish House Paia, Maui, HI 96779
8 Overall
Huelo Point Flower Farm Huelo Point Flower Farm Between mile markers 3 and 4. P.O. Box 1195, Paia, Maui, HI 96779
8 Overall