Traveler Reviews
| Overall |
- We feel that Matthews is the best restaurant in Northern Florida.
- We had a very good experience at Matthews.
- In our estimation, Matthew's is the finest restaurant in Jacksonville.
- Anyway it´s still the best place in the area and the food was very good again
- My husband took me to Matthew's for my birthday and it was a wonderful experience.
- Matthew's deserves all the business it can get, but this still made the dining experience slightly intimate and "cozy".
- My visit to Matthew's Restaurant for my 25th anniversary was superb.
- I couldn't have asked for a better experience.
- Matthew's has been one of our favorite restaurants to enjoy throughout the years....For special occassions or to just enjoy an upscale dining experience with friends, it is always our first choice.
- I was there about a two years ago for the first time and it was the best restuarant
- The restaurant was quiet
- As always, dining at Matthews is a memorable experience.
- A few breaks in service this trip, but overall still a wonderful experience.
- I will never come back here again, and will discourage coworkers & friends from goi g to dinner at this venue -
| Food |
- We love the food.
- The food was amazing.
- The food and service were outstanding.
- Good food, excellent service, great atmosphere.
- The food was spectacular!
- The food is consistently excellent and we have never been disappointed.
- great meal both off regular menu and special wine/food paring.
- The menu was original and creative with reasonable prices for the high quality of the food.
- The food was great!
- The food was fine, but it wasn't anything particularly special.
- the food was amazing as usual.
- I especially loved the Kalamata olive bread, and the sprimp appetizer.
- Great service and delicious food.
- Beautiful presentation, our entrees were cooked to perfection.
- Food was very good, service and attention better than most.
- The food was good, but it did not blow us away.
- The menu was thoughtfully developed that evening with what I felt was an excellent variety showcasing a great cross section of techniques and talents....He made the night even more enjoyable through his recommendations, insight into ingredients and methods and his notable yet appropriately reserved enthusiasm.
- Matthew's deserves all the business it can get, but this still made the dining experience slightly intimate and "cozy".
- The food was fantastic
- The food was amazing
- All were excellent with very nice presentation and special subtle acknowledgement of my birthday dinners which they appreciated.
- Fabulous service and fantastic food!
- The food is amazing and the service is always fantastic.
- The food here was amazing.
- The food was very interesting.
- Food was excellent, however the wait staff needed to.
- food was fantastic -
- Enjoyed the dinner
- I would highly recommend the restaurant to anyone who enjoys good food,wine and excellent service.
- Fantastic food, even better service.
- Definately, a fine dining experience worth repeating.
- The food is superb and the service is impeccable.
- Food was great, ambiance TERRIBLE.
- The wait staff was phenomenal (thank you David), the food was exceptional
- Food always well prepared....the short rib/flatiron duo was excellent....The flatiron steak wasn't the best cut.
- the chef's tasting menu was outstanding with an extraordinary blend of flavors, expertly complemented by the wine selections (with some surprising pairings that worked exquisitely)!
- Food good but not as remarkable as promoted
- The food was great, the service was extremely awkward....I will never come back here again, and will discourage coworkers & friends from goi g to dinner at this venue -
- As usual Matthews stands out as the model (seldom followed) of what a new-style high-end dining joint should be....Courteous and prompt service, seldom obtrusive, excellent food of course
| Service |
- The waiter was very pleasant
- The food and service were outstanding.
- Good food, excellent service, great atmosphere.
- From start to finish, our waiter was very attentive
- The service was very attentive, and the food was precisely prepared.
- The service was outstanding, attentive without being obtrusive.
- My last two visits to Matthew's have yielded poor service.
- But the service was very slow, our appetizers took a long time to come!
- The overall service was good this time
- Great service and delicious food.
- The service was phenomenal
- However, the service was still as excellent as possible, which was quite impressive considering
- the service was the highlight of the evening.
- Friendly and warm with impeccable service!
- Fabulous service and fantastic food!
- The food is amazing and the service is always fantastic.
- The service was unbelievable, but this past weekend I attended with a special someone and it was 100% opposite.
- However, the service and presentation was impeccable
- Food was excellent, however the wait staff needed to.
- service was the best.
- Service was excellent.
- Our waiter, Lawrence was outstanding!
- Fantastic food, even better service.
- Wait staff was very professional and attentive.
- The food is superb and the service is impeccable.
- Loud with crowded tables and sub par service.
- The wait staff was phenomenal (thank you David), the food was exceptional
- The staff were extremely attentive and service was excellent!
- The food was great, the service was extremely awkward.
- Courteous and prompt service, seldom obtrusive, excellent food of course
- The service is thoughtfully attentive, never too much
| Ambience |
- Good food, excellent service, great atmosphere.
- there was a loud table of 4 that annoyed us through our entire meal.
- And it's located in a charming section of Jacksonville.
- Beautiful presentation, our entrees were cooked to perfection.
- It has a nice ambiance.
- All were excellent with very nice presentation and special subtle acknowledgement of my birthday dinners which they appreciated.
- However, the service and presentation was impeccable
- The restaurant was quiet
- Very nice presentation and flavor.
- The ambiance is smooth, unintrusive and enjoyable.
- Food was great, ambiance TERRIBLE....Loud with crowded tables and sub par service.
- the atmosphere was perfect.
- Each time we dine there, we are always inspired by a previously unknown flavor, unusual spice combination or lovely presentation.
| Value |
- The menu was original and creative with reasonable prices for the high quality of the food.
- They have a very extensive wine list with pretty reasonable prices.
- Their cocktail prices are very reasonable.
Top Rated Restaurants in Jacksonville
| Restaurant Orsay Jacksonville, FL |
9
Overall
|
|
| Matthew's Jacksonville, FL 32207-3370 |
8.5
Overall
|
|
![]() |
bb's Jacksonville, FL 32207-8307 |
8
Overall
|
Top Rated Hotels in Jacksonville
| Staybridge Suites Jacksonville Jacksonville, FL 32216 |
9
Overall
|
|
![]() |
The Jenks House Jacksonville, FL 32205-7414 |
9
Overall
|
| Hyatt Place Jacksonville Airport Jacksonville, FL 32218 |
9
Overall
|
Restaurants in Top Destinations
- New York City Restaurants
- Buenos Aires Restaurants
- Orlando Restaurants
- Sao Paulo Restaurants
- Miami Beach Restaurants
- Montreal Restaurants
- Rio de Janeiro Restaurants
- Lima Restaurants
- Kissimmee Restaurants
- Charlotte Restaurants
- Santiago Restaurants
- Miami Restaurants
- San Carlos de Bariloche Restaurants
- Phoenix Restaurants
- Fort Lauderdale Restaurants
- Tampa Restaurants
- Bogota Restaurants
- Nashville Restaurants
- Columbus Restaurants
- Toronto Restaurants
- Cusco Restaurants
- Quebec City Restaurants
- Memphis Restaurants
- Jacksonville Restaurants
- Denver Restaurants
- Vancouver Restaurants
- Quito Restaurants
- Portland Restaurants
- Mar del Plata Restaurants
- Honolulu Restaurants





